Search

Meeting 4: Task Force on Long Sentences

At CCJ’s Task Force on Long Sentences’ fourth meeting (May 11, 2022), members examined how legislatures have shaped the nation’s use of long sentences. Task Force Director John Maki provided an overview of the significant diversity that characterizes our nation’s sentencing systems, the primary statutory mechanism that legislatures have used to increase prison sentences and time served requirements, and social science findings about what drives policymakers to enact long sentences legislation.

Key Findings from the Presentation

  • For much of the 20th century, the U.S. used “traditional” indeterminate sentencing, typically justified by the ideal of rehabilitation (National Research Council, 2014).
  • From the 1970s through 1990s, in part in response to a prolonged spike in violent crime, legislatures attempted to take varying degrees of control of the implementation of sentences and time served through limiting or abolishing parole and passing laws that mandated minimum sentences and time served requirements (National Research Council, 2014; Stemen et al, 2006).
  • Social psychology finds that punishment decisions tend to be “intuitively made” and “just deserts based” (Darley, 2010).
  • Spikes in violent crime rates, media coverage of crime, and appeals to punitive policies have historically mobilized voters, including Black communities and leaders (Picket, 2019; Forman, 2012).
  • Consideration of individualized fairness and procedural justice can moderate intuitive punitiveness (Darley, 2010).

Recent Posts

Crime Trends Working Group

Crime in Chicago: What You Need to Know

Two weeks after deploying military troops and federal law enforcement agents to Washington, DC, President Trump said he planned to take similar actions in Chicago, IL. This brief examines trends for 13 different crime types in Chicago going back to 2018.

Read More »
Council on Criminal Justice

Support our work

The Council on Criminal Justice is founded on the belief that a fair and effective criminal justice system is essential to democracy and a core measure of our nation’s well-being.

Your tax-deductible support ensures that the Council can advance solutions that enhance safety and justice for all.

Skip to content